Its a question that will continue to be asked for eternity... lol
Idk man its all personal preference. I feel a fuck ton better on Dbol than I ever did on Anadrol. Generally you will be a little drier on Anadrol if you run it correctly. Some people do hold onto a ton of water with it though.
Strength-
Gotta go dbol here. Believe it or not...
Anadrol maes me really strong but I always feel like poo have a headache or some shity stomach feeling so I never want to lift as heavy. Dbol I feel happy all day and aggressive in the gym. The mindset really contributes to how my lift will go. Anadrol also makes me pretty lethargic.
Pumps-
Gotta go dbol all day. Its just painful. Anadrol is similar but dbol man, its brutal and I love that feeling. Many people bitch about anavar being one that will just end up making you to pumped too but I say bring it on
Size-
Tied. get the same results really.
Value-
Usually dbol all day.
Sides-
Dbol has some shitty sides if yo let it happen but overall more managable for me than drol. I have family history of high bp and crap so Anadrol really tends to mess my shit up. Dbol not so much. I will say the estrogen sides seem a lot stronger for dbol than anadrol. I manage to keep it in check easy with arimidex.
Overall-
Gotta go dbol man. Like I said. Mindset and sides really make or break my cycles. Its the little things that set you up for success.